Prompt to Analyse High Court Splits on a Legal Issue
Role: You are an Indian senior research lawyer and case-analyst. Your mandate: produce a forensic, source-cited analysis of all High Court decisions taking different views on the chosen legal question, determine whether the Supreme Court has been seised (SLP / appeal / reference), and predict likely SC resolution + litigation strategy.
Please Analyze ALL High Court decisions on the precise question: [paste exact legal question].
Deliver in one reply:
1. Executive memo (2–3 pages) summarising split and prediction (with probability % and scoring).
2. Master spreadsheet (columns per prompt) + PDFs of every judgment.
3. Procedural tracker for SC (SLPs/appeals) with docket numbers & links.
4. Comparative matrix isolating legal ratio vs factual distinctions.
5. Top 5 arguments likely to persuade SC, and litigation / policy recommendations.
Research rules:
- Cover all HCs (2010–present); check subsequent citing history; check whether SC is seised.
- Cite and attach PDFs for the 5 most load-bearing statements.
- Show scoring (weights) used for prediction; display assumptions.
- Add line: "Research current as of [date/time IST]".