top of page
Legal News and Updates


No Fundamental Right to WhatsApp Access, Rules SC, Nudging Users Towards Indigenous Apps
The Supreme Court ruled that there is no fundamental right to access a specific private app like WhatsApp, distinguishing it from the right to internet access. The Court suggested using the indigenous app, Arattai, framing the issue as a contractual, not constitutional, dispute.

Chintan Shah
Oct 145 min read


Constitution Bench Redefines Judicial Ascent, Opens District Judge Quota to Serving Officers
The SC ruled that in-service judicial officers are eligible for the "Bar Quota" for direct recruitment as District Judges (DJ). The decision overturns a restrictive interpretation of Article 233(2), allowing officers with seven years of combined experience to apply.

Chintan Shah
Oct 144 min read


SC Reopens Debate on Voting Rights for Undertrial Prisoners, Challenges Blanket Ban
The SC is re-examining the blanket ban on voting rights for undertrial prisoners under Section 62(5) of the RP Act. The PIL argues the ban violates the presumption of innocence and Article 14 by treating undertrials the same as convicted prisoners.

Chintan Shah
Oct 146 min read


DNA Chain-of-Custody Failures: Supreme Court Acquits Two in 2012 Child Rape-Murder
On 26 August 2025, the SC acquitted two men convicted for the 2012 rape-murder of a 12-year-old, citing inadequate DNA and forensic evidence. The Court overturned Putai’s death sentence and Dileep’s life term, underscoring the need for reliable scientific evidence in criminal trials. This precedent strengthens the defence’s ability to challenge weak forensic links in sexual offence prosecutions.

Chintan Shah
Sep 23 min read


Supreme Court Permits Reopening of Death Sentence under Manoj Safeguards
In a landmark order, the SC allowed death row convict Vasanta Sampat Dupare to reopen sentencing, citing non-compliance with Manoj v. State of MP (2022) safeguards. By invoking Article 32 as a corrective tool, the Court has carved a narrow but powerful remedy for capital cases. Defence lawyers gain a new pathway to challenge final death sentences where procedural safeguards are breached.

Chintan Shah
Sep 23 min read


CJI Gavai Defends 'Creamy Layer' in SC/ST Reservations, Citing Article 14
CJI Gavai defended introducing a ‘creamy layer’ in SC reservations, arguing it refines affirmative action by ensuring benefits reach the most disadvantaged. The move signals a constitutional shift in balancing equity, efficiency, and social justice.

Chintan Shah
Aug 254 min read


Supreme Court to Re-Hear Maratha Reservation Plea
The Supreme Court of India is set to re-hear the Maratha reservation plea, challenging the Bombay High Court's interim order on the Maharashtra State SEBC Act, 2024. This follows a 2021 SC ruling that struck down a similar quota for exceeding the 50% reservation cap (Indra Sawhney judgment). The new 2024 Act grants a provisional 10% reservation, pushing Maharashtra's total to 62%, again citing "exceptional circumstances."

Chintan Shah
Jul 225 min read


Purposive Interpretation: Securing Inheritance Rights for Transgender Persons
In a significant ruling, the Calcutta High Court has affirmed the right of a transgender person to inherit ancestral property under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The Court applied a purposive interpretation to the term 'son' to include transgender individuals who identify as male. This judgment gives effect to the spirit of the Supreme Court's NALSA decision, recognizing that gender identity, not biological sex at birth, is the core of the matter for civil rights.

Chintan Shah
Jul 153 min read


‘We Need More Bold & Courageous Judges’: Justice Ujjal Bhuyan Emphasizes Judiciary’s Role in Protecting the Constitution
Justice Ujjal Bhuyan calls for bold, independent judges to protect India’s Constitution and democracy.

Chintan Shah
Jun 302 min read


‘Offending Sentiments’: A Growing Judicial Trend That Threatens Free Speech
Courts are shaping free speech by feelings—offense, not law, is becoming the new limit. A quiet rewrite of Article 19(1)(a).

Chintan Shah
Jun 234 min read


Supreme Court Declares Right to Appeal Conviction as Constitutional, Not Just Statutory
SC rules: Right to appeal a conviction is not just statutory—it’s a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution.

Chintan Shah
Jun 234 min read


Debate Rekindled Over 3-Year Bar Practice Rule for Judicial Appointments in India
Review petitions filed challenging India's 3-year Bar practice rule for judicial service, citing fairness and constitutional issues.

Chintan Shah
Jun 165 min read


No Individual Should Be Forcibly Subjected to Narco-Analysis”: Supreme Court Reaffirms Constitutional Safeguards in Amlesh Kumar Case
Introduction Case Analysis: Amlesh Kumar v. State of Bihar , Criminal Appeal No. __ of 2025 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 5392 of 2024)...

Chintan Shah
Jun 104 min read


Preventive Detention Is a Draconian Measure”: Supreme Court Quashes Kerala Detention Order in Dhanya M Case
SC calls preventive detention a “draconian measure” and quashes Kerala order for lack of public order threat.

Chintan Shah
Jun 94 min read


Kerala HC: Differently-Abled Employees Shouldn’t Suffer Due to Lack of Infrastructure
Differently-abled employee can't be penalised for govt’s failure to ensure accessible infrastructure: Kerala High Court

Chintan Shah
Jun 92 min read


Article 142 Has Become a 'Nuclear Missile': Vice President Dhankhar Criticizes Supreme Court's Direction to President
Vice President Dhankhar criticizes Supreme Court’s ruling on presidential timelines, calls Article 142 a "nuclear missile."

Chintan Shah
Apr 213 min read


The Right to Life and Personal Liberty: Supreme Court Upholds Fundamental Rights in Prabir Purkayastha Case
Supreme Court reinforces constitutional rights in Prabir Purkayastha case, emphasizing the right to life and personal liberty.

Chintan Shah
May 17, 20244 min read
bottom of page